Saturday, February 20, 2010

Shifting Coalitions?

Political parties are interesting as they often bring together diverse individuals who agree on a core set of issues but disagree over what appear to be less important issues. Since the importance of this or that issue depends on what political cards are currently being played and what cards are anticipated in the future, the core set of issues might change from time to time. If there is wide spread disagreement about those issues outside the core, coalitions are likely to shift through time. Perhaps we are on the verge of such a shift.

To simplify, we can think of the GOP at present as being comprised of three groups: neocons, traditional conservatives, and neoliberals. Neocons are in favor of interventionism, both home and abroad. Traditional conservatives support free markets, but also support "traditional conservative values" and don't mind using the state to enforce said values. Neoliberals are in favor of free markets and, even though some may share the conservative values of their traditional conservative allies, they do not advocate using government power to legislate those values. I do not see the neoliberals and neocons finding common ground. So the question is: will traditional conservatives downplay their state-supported values in order to side with neoliberals or reject their free market stance in order to side with neocons?

The sides have been drawn but it isn't clear how things will end. Consider these two videos from CPAC.




It should be interesting.

6 comments:

Justin M Ross said...

Traditional conservatives support free markets, but also support "traditional conservative values" and don't mind using the state to enforce said values.

I think traditional conservatives only support tradition/cultural values. Since our tradition includes at least relatively free markets, they at least in name support free markets but are very fickle friends. I think the best way to think of conservatives is to think of them as trying to ensure the autoregressive coefficient is equal to one, which is why you get conservatives who say things like "get your government hands off my Medicare."

Will Luther said...

Are you predicting they'll side with the neocons?

Justin M Ross said...

I would make a small-to-medium wager in that direction, yes. Like you said, it depends on what political cards are currently being played and what is anticipated in the future.

Anonymous said...

Nice post and this post helped me alot in my college assignement. Say thank you you seeking your information.

オテモヤン said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.