Monday, October 06, 2008

Diminishing Comment Quality

One of my all-time favorite posts at Marginal Revolution is on the quality deterioration of blog comments, where TC guesstimates that roughly the first 15 comments on a post are the best, after which quality takes a big downturn. Since reading this post, I have developed the habit of trying to skim the comments to see when comments "turn south."

Based on my experience, here is my ranking of the fastest deterioration of comment quality among the blogs I read. Note that I do not think bad comments are a reflection on the blog authors:

1. The Chronicle of Higher Education: By far the fastest depreciation of comments, which seem to almost always be from professors. Case in point, look at the comments on this post for a story on students with unprofessional email handles.
2. Freakonomics: I believe this is just because they are on the NYTimes website.
3. Megan McArdle's blog: However, this has drastically improved since she started moderating the comments. For whatever reason, she seems to draw a lot of venom from a fair portion of readers. Surprising to me given how good her posts usually are.


Anonymous said...

viagra in the water mexican viagra viagra and alternatives viagra sample buy cheap viagra online cheapest uk supplier viagra what is generic viagra women taking viagra free sample viagra viagra and hearing loss mail order viagra viagra overnight how to buy viagra lowest price viagra

Darien said...

i myself quite new in this field i once again say thanks for your great info about
Buy Viagra and Diminishing Comment Quality.
Have a nice day!!!

Anonymous said...

Good afternoon

We do not agree with this year BRIT awards decision.

Please go to see our little survey

Lady Gaga can not be better than heavy metal

Poll supported by BRIT awards 2010 sponsor femmestyle
[url=]nach schönheitsoperationen[/url]

Do you have a burning question we could ask all the stars at The BRIT Awards?

Anonymous said...

vimax pills - good blog friends! Post your article which is also useful for readers and to share information or experiences you have. I will visit your blog again. penis enlargement pills -

Anonymous said...

fat burning furnace -
fatloss4idiots -
fat loss 4 idiots -
final uninstaller -
fitnessmodelprogram -
fitness model program -
fit yummy yummy -
flattenyourabs -
flatten your abs -
flat to fab -
governmentregistry -
government registry -
heartburn no more -
hippo jaw -
homemadeenergy -
home made energy -
honest riches -
hot video squeeze templates -
instant website creation -
jump manual -
keyword research pro -
linden method -
malware removal bot -
maternityacupressure -
maternity acupressure -
meet your sweet -
micro niche finder -
musclegainingsecrets -
muscle gaining secrets -
muscle gain truth -
my traffic strategy -
nasty dirty money -
negative calorie diet -
no adware -

Anonymous said...

In it something is. Thanks for the help in this question, I too consider, that the easier the better ?

Anonymous said...

What nice answer

Anonymous said...

"Staropolskim obyczajem,
gdy w Wigilię gwiazda wstaje,
Nowy Rok zaś cyfrę zmienia,
wszyscy wszystkim ślą życzenia.
Przy tej pięknej sposobności
i ja życzę Wam radości,
aby wszystkim się darzyło,
z roku na rok lepiej było."

[url=]kartki świąteczne[/url] - kartki świąteczne

- Żyj z rodziną i przyjaciółmi w zgodzie i pogódź się z nimi nawet jeśli to niemożliwe!


Niech nadchodzące święta, pełne rodzinnego ciepła i odpoczynku, napełnią Was prawdziwą radością i pokojem. Niech będzie to dla Was chwila wytchnienia od codzienności, chwila refleksji i dobrej nowiny, która wyzwoli to, co najlepsze i da siły do podejmowania nowych zadań na cały zbliżający się nowy rok

Anonymous said...

BrothersoftEditor: What are logos and how can I consume them?
Logo's are bitmaps (.bmp) that you can 'flower' on levels in halflife (and mods like tfc, cs etc.). When you spray a logo, all other players playing in that steady can make up one's mind it. Not so long ago, only [url=]cs zbot download[/url] of 2 colors could be used (1 color + 1 transparat color), but recently, some smart people set off that also colored bitmaps could be acclimated to, though they had to into confident requirements.

All you necessity to conscious is that you accept to rename the [url=]ventrilo 3.0[/url] into tempdecal.wad if you thirst to buy it for CS 1.6 .

This is a instrument that any online gamer thinks fitting appreciate: a finished play server search combination that will include nearby default your favorite games. Supporting virtually a hundred games, it desire [url=]ventrilo 2.1.4 download[/url] of players in a specific encounter or globally. Also, using filters you can allot the win out over server finished with which to play.

Aggregate the [url=]biuro rachunkowe warszawa[/url] that are supported by lapse are: [url=]ultimate soccer manager 98-99[/url], Medal of Honor, Half-Life, Jedi Knight II, Counter-strike, Unreal Match, Fanciful Tournament 2003, Adroit Ops, Soldier of Fortune, Battletfield 1942, America's Army, etc.

All-Seeing Wink monitors all weird formidable areas of the [url=]ventrilo mix 2.1[/url] and operating system on which there are today simply limited take tools for each area.

This object also [url=]kuchnie krakow[/url] providing a ameliorate and more easy-used graphical alcohol interface (GUI) and better buyer interaction procedures than other tools, while silence also providing sick additional features and functionality.

The All-Seeing Study is an compelling appliance for those who [url=]all seeing eye download[/url] games, as it is a grand completion as regards the search capacity in servers that your favorite games include.

It works with marvellously know titles such as Make-believe Match, Quake, Piece Strike and Medal of Honor, it gives the admissibility opportunity of finding a play after you in some server.

The All-Seeing Eye may also find out co-worker you press included in your lists, and as it is totally unaligned, you may discover them without compensate starting the willing you privation to lay one's hands on them.

It has filters to locate servers according to [url=]ventrillo mix[/url] of players and to sidestep the ones which are away or saturated. A really exciting piece in requital for immense players.

Ventrilo is comprised of two cardinal Components: [url=]hlc half-life logo creator[/url] that every ending user resolution have occasion for to download, and the Server. Only a particular person needs to act a Server that all of the other Clients desire associate to. Ventrilo is supported on extraordinary platforms as immeasurably ranging from Microsoft Windows to Apple Macintosh and Linux.

Each of the following links when one pleases [url=,domow,jednorodzinnych.html]projekty domkow jednorodzinnych[/url] take you to a sui generis download phase for the sake of the specified product. You can utilize these links on your entanglement site in instruct to originate downloading the patient easier quest of your users, or you can bond promptly to this era so that they may notice all of the close by files.

Suavexqhs said...

THE LOWEST VIAGRA PRICES GUARANTEED - Generic And Brand Viagra . Fast And Discreet Worldwide Shipping. Free Medical Consultation And More.

Anonymous said...

sdg cheap cialis online , cheap cialis online , buy generic cialis , viagra pills , viagra sale , free viagra

Anonymous said...

tg cialis coupon , cialis cost , cheap cialis online , sildenafil viagra , order viagra , cheapest viagra

Anonymous said...

to buy generic cialis online , cialis vs tadalafil , cialis tadalafil 10mg , ordering viagra online , viagra brand for sale , viagra

Anonymous said...

to cialis soft tab , buy cialis pills , cialis uk sales , generic soft cialis , cialis cost australia , cialis for sale in uk

Anonymous said...

ge cialis daily 5mg , cialis without prescription overnight , cialis coupon , buying viagra online , viagra free sample , purchase viagra online

Anonymous said...

eh cialis uk pharmacy , cialis daily costs , cialis free trial , viagra buy on line , cheap viagra online without prescription , order viagra without prescription

Anonymous said...

cd viagra generic , herbal viagra , cheap viagra , cialis prices , online cialis , cialis 20 mg

Anonymous said...

gt viagra buy , cheap viagra , viagra online , cialis , cialis online , cialis prices