Saturday, May 31, 2008

How Many Serial Killers Equal One Genius?

After my class the other day, one of my students asked me about population growth and its effects over the next few generations for humanity. Paraphrased, it went like this:
Student: Our population cannot grow indefinitely, can it?
Me: Population growth in market societies is good for the forseeable future. It is not something that will likely ever need a planned solution to solve.
Student: Our resources are fixed though, just one planet.
Me: The only true natural resource is the human brain. Oil is a water and land ruining nuisance until a brain figures out how to turn it into energy. The more people, the more brains, the more likely we are to come up with geniuses who increase our possible resource set. We have a much larger population today than we did 100 years ago, yet we use much fewer resources to feed it.
Student: More people also mean more potential serial killers.
Me: Yes, but even a very successful serial killer is bad for 10 or 15 people, maybe 200 if you include extended family. But a genius benefits the entire population.
My last comment inspires this post. How many serial killers would it have to take before we would offset the gains by a single genius? The comments are open. My take is that it would have to be large, very large. If you were told that in the next 1 million people born there would be one genius that will make enormous contributions to the welfare of society, but also in that million people is X number of serial killers, how large would X have to be in order for you to be disappointed by this knowledge? No trick answers to this, like stating that the serial killers will kill the geniuses. You can comment that my calculus is cold, but your comment will not be interesting. Solve for x!

5 comments:

Matt E. Ryan said...

First and foremost, let's not mince words-- serial killers are bad. Very bad. Very very bad.

That being said, I'm not certain that serial killers are as bad as you make them out to be. Consider:

- On the minus side, serial killers remove productive members from society. This is bad. This is a reduction in the economic pie.

- We also have to expend resources looking for them. However, in a system of private protection, this would lead to wealth enhancing economic activity-- demand for protection could rise, and companies could provide this. We see a large cost to providing police services now, but that's within a system of takings and forced provision.

- On the plus side, serial killers sell more papers, get books devoted to them, get songs written about them, have their own biographies on A&E, and tours of their areas of carnage. Think Jack the Ripper and Charles Manson. These all increase the economic pie.

Obviously, this ignores the value of life; certainly a problem. But if you consider that serial killers tend to kill those on the lower end of the productive spectrum-- I think a reasonable assumption-- you could make an economic argument that serial killers could have welfare enhancing properties.

To that, more of both! Granted that isn't a stable equilibrium, but when the population becomes 50% serial killers...well, that might not be a welfare enhancing situation. So we could be in a region of locally welfare enhancing serial killers while globally we do see reductions in well being.

Bryce said...

The serial killer only needs to kill the genius prior to his or her "contribution to society."

Anonymous said...

Everyone wants to produce their own fashion statement, and it is easy to do with the numerous appealing pieces of clothing available today. Take advantage of the ideas in this article to find out what your style ought to say about you, and tips on how to attain the look you would like with the garments choices.

Always attire properly for your season. You are unable to plan to dress in exactly the same points all through the year due to weather alterations. Throughout the spring and summer months, put on smooth cloth apparel that is certainly decrease cut with dazzling shades.[url=http://www.cheapuggukbootssale.co.uk/ugg-kids-classic-short-c-2.html]cheap Ugg Kids Classic Short[/url] Throughout the slip and winter season, put on organic colours and materials, linen, pure cotton, and leather.

A simple black blazer is a wonderful accessory for any clothing collection. It can be used to dress up just about any attire. Then, you may remove it should you alteration to a much more casual place.[url=http://www.cheapuggukbootssale.co.uk/ugg-turn-cuff-gloves-c-17.html]cheap Ugg Turn Cuff Gloves[/url] The hue will also match essentially anything at all inside your cabinet, from jeans to enterprise casual blouses and slacks.

There are style ideas that seem fairly incredible by nature that you could usually rating points with.[url=http://www.cheapuggukbootssale.co.uk/ugg-kids-classic-short-c-2.html]cheap Ugg Kids Classic Short[/url] For instance, straps that be noticeable and articulate out are component of fashion in just about every length of time. Also, the classic dark skirt is always a success also, so attempt those two concepts out together!

Usually gown in a manner that satisfies your individuality. As an example,[url=http://www.cheapuggukbootssale.co.uk/ugg-classic-nightfall-c-6.html]cheap Ugg Classic Nightfall[/url] when you are a athletic person, wear informal apparel that may be layered and stylish. In the event you classify being a "rock chick," then will not be afraid to put on clashing apparel, but make sure you keep it womanly. By attempting to outfit in ways that fails to satisfy your persona, men and women observe.

If you are searching for a way to seem much better, this information has offered you some terrific tips on improving your style. Get free from that fashion decline and begin selecting looks based on the recommendations on this page. You will find you look greater than ever before and feel much better way too.[url=http://www.cheapuggukbootssale.co.uk/ugg-turn-cuff-gloves-c-17.html]cheap Ugg Turn Cuff Gloves[/url]

Anonymous said...

I think the admin of this web page is actually working hard in favor of his website, since here
every stuff is quality based data.
Feel free to surf my web site : how to make a bit of extra money

Anonymous said...

5 yuan celine bags all show celine bags Chinese initial understanding of luxury goods can be traced back 4 celine bags and no longer like before celine bags S celine bags